Melanie Chubb
English 100 Assignment #3: Film-Based argument Due date: Draft #2 by 11:59 on 4/4/17 Should Illegal Immigrants be Allowed in the United States? In the film, Survivor, screenwriter, Philip Shelby writes about Kate Abbott’s struggles with saving America from a terrorist attack. Abbott is a security service agent who will discover of a plot where an illegal sniper will shoot a gas bomb in Time Square in an attempt to kill thousands of innocent civilians. Members of her team, through death, deception, and false assumptions, she must fight the battle of survival against these trespassers, in order to save New York in another possible terrorist attack. This movie relates very well for a point to be made for the United States in relation to terrorist threats. Should Americans allow immigrants into the country? Should it be this easy for terrorists to walk into the United States? Or even, why is it so easy for for people to enter the U.S. just because we are to be known for being a “melting pot” country. A country that invites diversity with open arms, needs to have somewhat of a boundary to that statement. Things that Americans go through every day for foreigners to come into the United States, are crucial into feeling like a safe citizen of our own beautiful land. Seemingly, getting attacked frequently. Should Americans allow immigrants into their country?My opinion is no. Why is it so easy to let possible terrorists into the country, because they do not want to offend anyone? It’s crucial, that we, as Americans need to think about who we let in, to keep our land a better, and safer place.Things such as suspicion, over riding our population with non Americans, and bringing danger to our lives as Americans, in more ways than we know. These are all prime examples as to why immigrants should not be allowed in the country. Suspicion itself is a powerful thing. After the 9/11 attack in 2001, suspicion and uncertainty across the U.S. has made people angry and pure hatred towards immigrants and Muslims, in general. The responsibility that the “Muslims” had on 9/11, gave them the reputation of being the most hated group of people in America because they caused the greatest tragedy in all of America. A big problem and a great target here in the U.S., are airports around the world. Americans are very weary flying around the world because of past events shown. How Muslims, specifically, use airports to create havoc among American citizens. So many people are trying to fight back against racial profiling at traveling that it is hindering and doubting at the lives of people who actually live in our beautiful county. I get it, we are supposed to be a loving, melting pot of all sorts of diversity. But when your country has been attacked by bad foreigners trying to disguise themselves as regular citizens? It is difficult to decipher between the two. An article called, “How Did Hijackers Get Past Airport Security?” written by Michael A. Hiltzik, David Willman, and Alan C. Miller, for the Los Angeles Times, wrote, ”At almost every step along the way, the system posed no challenge to the terrorists--not to their ability to purchase tickets, to pass security checkpoints while carrying knives and cutting implements nor to board aircraft.” Since then, security has increased in United States Airports. In an article titled, "U.S. Airport Pat-Downs Are About to Get More Invasive" The Author, Justin Bachman states that, "Denver International Airport, for example, notified employees and flight crews on Thursday that the “more rigorous” searches “will be more thorough and may involve an officer making more intimate contact than before.” Showing, how security has increased and airports are becoming more drastic in their changes towards Americans becoming safe. Just like in Survivor, five men were questioned about their entrance into the U.S. They were claimed as being racially profiled and somehow allowed in the U.S. An article written by Stephen Jones for Mirror, wrote, “Five reasons why airports are prime targets for terrorists like ISIS in wake of Istanbul attacks” He gave examples as to why airports might be the main target for terrorists and why security at airports are dwindling. For example, “...Ultimately security checks can be a dehumanizing experience - so they remain kept to a minimum. Airports ultimately don't want to put off people using them.” (Jones) His fourth reason as to why airports are a prime target for terrorists, “The attacks are symbolic and airports are a status symbol of a nation” He elaborates more to the topic by saying, “Everyone uses airports - and they all look very similar - so when a terrorist incident happens, everyone can more easily imagine being there are wondering if it could have been them or could happen to them in future. Creating such fear is an aim of terrorists.“ (Jones) I understand, however, that we should all be loving and kind to all people. An Article posted by the American Immigration Council, titled, "How the United States Immigration System Works" wrote, "The Immigration and Naturalization Act (INA), the body of law governing current immigration policy, provides for an annual worldwide limit of 675,000 permanent immigrants, with certain exceptions for close family members. Lawful permanent residency allows a foreign national to work and live lawfully and permanently in the United States." Confirming, it is legally okay for immigrants to come into the United States by the Immigration Policy. But how many more innocent Americans are going to be killed because of these acts of “racial profiling being excused.” Another issue as to why we should not let immigrants in our country is the over population. Watson Institute for International Studies from Brown University stated that “if immigration continues at its current pace, more than fifty million newcomers will flood into the United States in the next half century, overloading our schools, hospitals, and other social services”(Brown). Seemingly, leaving no space for our own citizens. Prioritizing foreigners before our own citizens is becoming an overwhelming problem. Brown University also contributed the fact that, “The continual arrival of large numbers of immigrants, both legal and illegal, will eventually overwhelm American culture and contribute to the fragmentation of our society.”(Brown) Welcoming in Immigrants into the United States and being so welcoming is so natural for the U.S. However, Over population is a great example as to why, I believe, the United States should not allow immigrants into the country. In the NewsMax article, “16 reasons Donald Trump Is Not Wrong on Immigration,” by Jim Meyers states multiple times how dangerous having immigrants in our country are, in more ways than we think about. “About 4.5 million illegal aliens in the U.S. drive on a regular basis, many without licenses or insurance or even the ability to read road signs written in English (Meyers). "The New York Times reported in Arizona that 63 percent of cited drivers have no license, no insurance, and no registration for the vehicle, and 97 percent of them are illegal aliens. Of the 188,380 deportations of illegal aliens in one recent year, 23 percent had committed criminal traffic offenses, primarily driving under the influence. Rep. Steve King of Iowa has estimated that illegal alien drunk drivers kill 13 Americans every day.” (Meyers) I understand, accidents happen, and I'm not blaming illegal aliens on these accidents alone. However, It is a scary fact that you could be killed driving, because of stupid decisions by the illegal aliens for driving in the U.S. I get that American citizens are guilty for all of this as well. But if we can stop the dangers that this is becoming, why wouldn't we? Suspicion, over riding our population with non Americans, and bringing danger to our lives, as Americans, in more ways than we know are crucial aspects that we, as Americans, need to think about to keep our land a better, and safer place. However, I get it. I do. We are the land of a melting pot and a free country to foreigners who want to chase the “American Dream” and live a free life. However, if we keep getting these terroristic attacks, like the ones Kate Abbott did in, “Survivor,” the good guys, might not able to outsmart the bad ones in future attacks. Clearly, this whole, “melting pot” of a country is not working for us anymore. We are at war with many different countries! Especially, in the Middle East. I believe, it is very normal to be wary of the certain type of people we are at war with, in our country. Think about this. Anybody who are criticized Islam and Muslims are seen as racist or scums of the earth. When really, those who are, are the ones who are trying to prevent any possible terrorist attack and care about our own people. Why does these type of people, get the blame for what others have done? A prime example as to why we need immigrants in America was a quote directly taken from an article called, "Benefits of Immigration Outweigh the Costs" by, Pia Orrenius. They show a statistic that is quite astonishing. "Forty-four percent of medical scientists are foreign born, for example, as are 42 percent of computer software developers. Immigrant workers are also over represented among college professors, engineers, mathematicians, nurses, doctors and dentists, to name a few." If immigration makes the economy larger, more efficient and productive, what’s the problem? Why do we, as a nation, strictly limit immigration? However, I still believe the down sides mean much more that what I believe Americans can do for our country as well. After watching videos right after the attack in London, a man in a trending interview, right after the London attack stated,“The blood of our own citizens is in the hands of those who allow these things to happen. Politicians and the media especially are allowing this to happen because our own citizens and people around the world are fighting so hard for equality, making it easier for terrorist to get in without question and possibly become your next door neighbor.” We might not have a Kate Abbott on our team like “Survivor” did in possible future attacks. It’s a scary thought to think about if fighting the battle against Trump to keep foreigners out of the United States to protect us, is really worth it? Brown University. "US Immigration Policy: What Should We Do?" Studylib.net. Watson Institute for International Studies, n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2017. Hiltzik, Michael A., and David Willman. "How Did Hijackers Get Past Airport Security?"Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles Times, 23 Sept. 2001. Web. 25 Apr. 2017. "How the United States Immigration System Works." American Immigration Council. N.p., 30 Jan. 2017. Web. 04 May 2017. Jones, Stephen. "Five Reasons Airports Are Prime Terrorist Targets in Wake of Istanbul Attacks." Mirror. Mirror, 29 June 2016. Web. 25 Apr. 2017. Meyers, Jim. "16 Reasons Donald Trump Is Not Wrong on Immigration." Newsmax. Newsmax, 08 July 2015. Web. 25 Apr. 2017.
0 Comments
Melanie Chubb
English 100 Assignment #3: Film-Based argument Due date: Draft #2 by 11:59 on 4/4/17 I Get It. In the film, Survivor, screenwriter, Philip Shelby writes about Kate Abbott’s struggles with saving America from a terrorist attack. Abbott is a security service agent who will discover of a plot where an illegal sniper will shoot a gas bomb in Time Square in an attempt to kill thousands of innocent civilians. Members of her team, through death, deception, and false assumptions, she must fight the battle of survival against these trespassers, in order to save New York in another possible terrorist attack. This movie relates very well for a point to be made for the United States in relation to terrorist threats. Should Americans allow immigrants into the country? Should it be this easy for terrorists to walk into the United States? Or even, why is it so easy for for people to enter the U.S. just because we are to be known for being a “melting pot” country. A country that invites diversity with open arms, needs to have somewhat of a boundary to that statement. Things that Americans go through every day for foreigners to come into the United States, are crucial into feeling like a safe citizen of our own beautiful land. Seemingly, getting attacked frequently. Things such as suspicion, over riding our population with non Americans, and bringing danger to our lives as Americans, in more ways than we know. These are all prime examples as to why immigrants should not be allowed in the country. Why is it so easy to let possible terrorists into the country, because they do not want to offend anyone? It’s crucial, that we, as Americans need to think about who we let in, to keep our land a better, and safer place. Suspicion itself is a powerful thing. After the 9/11 attack in 2001, suspicion and uncertainty across the U.S. has made people angry and pure hatred towards immigrants and muslims, in general. The responsibility that the “muslims” had on 9/11, gave them the reputation of being the most hated group of people in America because they caused the greatest tragedy in all of America. A big problem and a great target here in the U.S., are airports around the world. Americans are very weary flying around the world because of past events shown. How muslims, specifically, use airports to create havoc among American citizens. So many people are trying to fight back against racial profiling at traveling that it is hindering and doubting at the lives of people who actually live in our beautiful county. I get it, we are supposed to be a loving, melting pot of all sorts of diversity. But when your country has been attacked by bad foreigners trying to disguise themselves as regular citizens? It is difficult to decipher between the two. An article called, “How Did Hijackers Get Past Airport Security?” written by Michael A. Hiltzik, David Willman, and Alan C. Miller, for the Los Angeles Times, wrote,”At almost every step along the way, the system posed no challenge to the terrorists--not to their ability to purchase tickets, to pass security checkpoints while carrying knives and cutting implements nor to board aircraft.” Just like in Survivor, five men were questioned about their entrance into the U.S. They were claimed as being racially profiled and somehow allowed in the U.S. An article written by Stephen Jones for Mirror, wrote an article called, “Five reasons why airports are prime targets for terrorists like ISIS in wake of Istanbul attacks” He gave examples as to why Airports might be the main target for terrorists and why security at airports are dwindling. For example, “...Ultimately security checks can be a dehumanising experience - so they remain kept to a minimum. Airports ultimately don't want to put off people using them.” (Jones) His fourth reason as to why airports are a prime target for terrorists, “The attacks are symbolic and airports are a status symbol of a nation” He elaborates more to the topic by saying, “Everyone uses airports - and they all look very similar - so when a terrorist incident happens, everyone can more easily imagine being there are wondering if it could have been them or could happen to them in future. Creating such fear is an aim of terrorists.“ (Jones) I get it. we should all be loving and kind to all people. But enough is enough. How many more innocent Americans are going to be killed because of these acts of “racial profiling.” Another issue as to why we should not let immigrants in our country is the over population. Watson Institute for International Studies from Brown University stated that “if immigration continues at its current pace, more than fifty million newcomers will flood into the United States in the next half century, overloading our schools, hospitals, and other social services”(Brown). High levels of immigration will deprive American workers of jobs while forcing government to spend more on the needs of immigrants. Leaving no space for our own citizens, to be left homeless, rotting away, and possibly dead on the streets of our own country.! Brown University also contributed the fact that, “The continual arrival of large numbers of immigrants, both legal and illegal, will eventually overwhelm American culture and contribute to the fragmentation of our society.”(Brown) In the NewsMax article, “16 reasons Donald Trump Is Not Wrong on Immigration,” by Jim Meyers states multiple times how dangerous having immigrants in our country are, in more ways than we think about. “About 4.5 million illegal aliens in the U.S. drive on a regular basis, many without licenses or insurance or even the ability to read road signs written in English (Meyers). The New York Times reported. In Arizona, 63 percent of cited drivers have no license, no insurance, and no registration for the vehicle, and 97 percent of them are illegal aliens. Of the 188,380 deportations of illegal aliens in one recent year, 23 percent had committed criminal traffic offenses, primarily driving under the influence. Rep. Steve King of Iowa has estimated that illegal alien drunk drivers kill 13 Americans every day.” (Meyers) Suspicion, over riding our population with non Americans, and bringing danger to our lives, as Americans, in more ways than we know are crucial aspects that we, as Americans, need to think about to keep our land a better, and safer place. However, I get it. I do. We are the land of a melting pot and a free country to foreigners who want to chase the “American Dream” and live a free life. However, if we keep getting these terroristic attacks, like the ones Kate Abbott did in, “Survivor,” the good guys, might not able to outsmart the bad ones in future attacks. Clearly, this whole, “melting pot” of a country is not working for us anymore. We are at war with many different countries! Especially, in the Middle East. It would be crazy if we did not stereotype a certain type of people who are trying to fight the world, and our country especially. Think about this. Anybody who are criticized Islam and Muslims are seen as racist or scums of the earth. When really, those who are, are the ones who are trying to prevent any possible terrorist attack and care about our own people. A man in a trending interview, right after the London attack stated,“The blood of our own citizens is in the hands of those who allow these things to happen. Politicians and the media especially are allowing this to happen because our own citizens and people around the world are fighting so hard for equality, making it easier for terrorist to get in without question and possibly become your next door neighbor.” We might not have a Kate Abbott on our team like “Survivor” did in possible future attacks. It’s a scary thought. I get it. Do you? English 100 Assignment #3: Film-Based argument Due date: Draft #1 by 11:59 on 3/23 I get it. In the film, Survivor, screenwriter, Philip Shelby writes about Kate Abbott’s struggles with saving America from a terrorist attack. Abbott is a security service agent who will discover of a plot where an illegal sniper will shoot a gas bomb in Time Square in an attempt to kill thousands of innocent civilians. Members of her team, through death, deception, and false assumptions, she must fight the battle of survival against these trespassers, in order to save New York in another possible terrorist attack. This movie relates very well for a point to be made for the United States in relation to terrorist threats. Should Americans allow immigrants into the country? Should it be this easy for terrorists to walk into the United States? Or even, why is it so easy for for people to enter the U.S. just because we are to be known for being a “melting pot” country. A country that invites diversity with open arms, needs to have somewhat of a boundary to that statement. Things that Americans go through every day for foreigners to come into the U.S.A are crucial into feeling like a safe citizen of our own beautiful land. Seemingly, getting attacked more and more. Things such as suspicion, over riding our population with non Americans, and bringing danger to our lives, as Americans, in more ways than we know are crucial aspects that we, as Americans need to think about to keep our land a better, and safer place. Suspicion itself is a powerful thing. After the 9/11 attack in 2001, suspicion and uncertainty across the U.S. has made people angry and hatred towards immigrants and Muslims in general. The responsibility that the Muslim group had on 9/11, gave them the reputation of being the most hated group of people in America because they caused the greatest tragedy in all of America. A big problem and a great target here in the U.S., are airports around the world. Americans are very weary flying around the world because of past events shown. How Muslims, specifically, use airports to create havoc among American citizens. So many people are trying to fight back against racial profiling at traveling that it is hindering and doubting at the lives of people who actually live in our beautiful county. I get it, we are supposed to be a loving, melting pot of all sorts of diversity. But when your country has been attacked by bad foreigners trying to disguise themselves as regular citizens? It is difficult to decipher between the two. Just like in Survivor, five men were questioned about their entrance into the U.S. They were claimed as being racially profiled and somehow allowed in the U.S. I get it. we should all be loving and kind to all people. But enough is enough. How many more innocent Americans are going to be killed because of these acts of “racial profiling.” Another issue as to why we should not let immigrants in our country is the over population. Watson Institute for International Studies from Brown University stated that if immigration continues at its current pace, more than fifty million newcomers will flood into the United States in the next half century, overloading our schools, hospitals, and other social services. High levels of immigration will deprive American workers of jobs while forcing government to spend more on the needs of immigrants. Leaving no space for our own citizens, to be left homeless and dead on the streets of our own country. Brown University also contributed the fact that The continual arrival of large numbers of immigrants, both legal and illegal, will eventually overwhelm American culture and contribute to the fragmentation of our society. In the NewsMax article, “16 reasons Donald Trump Is Not Wrong on Immigration,” It states multiple times how dangerous having immigrants in our country are, in more ways than we think about. “About 4.5 million illegal aliens in the U.S. drive on a regular basis, many without licenses or insurance or even the ability to read road signs written in English, The New York Times reported. In Arizona, 63 percent of cited drivers have no license, no insurance, and no registration for the vehicle, and 97 percent of them are illegal aliens. Of the 188,380 deportations of illegal aliens in one recent year, 23 percent had committed criminal traffic offenses, primarily driving under the influence. Rep. Steve King of Iowa has estimated that illegal alien drunk drivers kill 13 Americans every day.” Suspicion, over riding our population with non Americans, and bringing danger to our lives, as Americans, in more ways than we know are crucial aspects that we, as Americans need to think about to keep our land a better, and safer place. However, I get it. I do. We are the land of a melting pot and a free country to foreigners who want to chase the “American Dream” and live a free life. However, if we keep getting these terrorist attacks, like the ones Kate Abbott did in, “Survivor,” the good guys, might not able to outsmart the bad ones the next time. Clearly, this whole, “melting pot” of a country is not working for us anymore. We are at war with Islam! It would be crazy if we did not stereotype a certain type of people who are trying to fight the world, and our country especially. Think about this. Anybody who are criticized Islam and Muslims are seen as racist or scums of the earth. When really, those who are, are the ones who are trying to prevent any possible terrorist attack and care about our own people. “The blood of our own citizens is in the hands of those who allow these things to happen.”Politicians and the media especially are allowing this to happen because our own citizens and people around the world are fighting so hard for equality, making it easier for terrorist to get in without question and possibly become your next door neighbor. We might not have a Kate Abbott on our team like “Survivor” did in possible future attacks. I get it. Do you? |
Melanie
Here I will be blogging about my thoughts and ideas. Archives
May 2017
Categories
All
|